Mediatel Logo original-file's-desc Mediatel Logo Connected: Display Connected: Media Landscape Connected: Regional Connected: AV Consumer Surveys Connected: Direct LinkedIn LinkedIn logo icon Twitter Twitter logo icon Youtube Youtube logo icon Flickr Flickr logo icon Instagram Instagram logo icon Mail Mail icon Down arrow

The out-of-home commercial model is broken - programmatic is the fix

05 Jun 2018  |  Dan Larden 
The out-of-home commercial model is broken - programmatic is the fix

Major structural changes need to be made if out-of-home is to reap the digital rewards on offer, writes Dan Larden

Out-of-Home (OOH) is at a pivotal point. The sector has been transformed in recent years; pixels have replaced print in terms of the type of media we see on our streets, and brands have a greater opportunity to plug into a bright digital future.

Greater automation and, ultimately, a programmatic approach are key to driving this continued growth in digital out-of-home (DOOH). The benefits to brands - being able to run simultaneous and synced mobile, display and OOH campaigns from one buying console - are clear.

And while there are nuances to buying OOH (with one ‘impression’ potentially viewed by thousands), programmatic is really the only buying and selling methodology truly fit for a digital age.

And yet programmatic remains more vision than reality in DOOH. A variety of factors are hampering the sector’s pivot towards programmatic, and changes need to be made if OOH is to reap the digital rewards on offer.

Pivot to programmatic

Change has been relatively slow to come to OOH, where media planning and buying decisions are largely controlled by a select few specialist players that are either owned by, or closely linked with, major holding companies. Relationships between these agencies and the media owners in OOH are deeply entrenched in a nod to the sector’s legacy approach.

The problem being that where there are legacy approaches, non-transparent remuneration models can flourish. A recent report by management consultancy McKinsey found that rebates and commission remain a “fundamental part” of the advertising ecosystem - and they are certainly not uncommon in OOH.

That means there is the potential for decisions to be made in the interests of an outdated (and self-serving) commercial model rather than exclusively in the interests of clients. As McKinsey highlights, advertisers are understandably finding themselves questioning what they are paying for, asking if they are getting all they are entitled to from their spend. With OOH representing a £1.1 billion market in the UK in 2017, the stakes are high.

This stands in contrast to the relatively new world of programmatic, where transparency and efficiency - so important in today’s media buying world - is becoming the expectation. There is a need, therefore, to bring greater clarity and transparency to the DOOH supply chain. Fully opening up the sector to a programmatic approach could deliver greater ROI for advertisers through an investment model that avoids hidden margins.

But that can’t happen without the structural investment needed to bring greater automation to creative, planning and execution of DOOH campaigns. Media owners and specialist OOH agencies are making that investment - but it needs to accelerate if DOOH is to catch-up to where it needs to be.

For example, consolidating inventory and making placements more easily accessible to programmatic buyers is long overdue.

And even switching just the buying methodology to programmatic can increase ROI by taking back some of the hidden margins being transparently taken from brands’ budgets.

The new systems required to support this programmatic shift must also be supported by an investment in data. Location is an inherent benefit of DOOH campaigns but better audience targeting and measurement can make them even more effective.

If programmatic capabilities in OOH campaigns can be unlocked in this way, there is then the potential of creating links to other complementary programmatically-traded channels.

Mobile, for example, is an ideal partner for building on the location-based strengths of OOH, with its ability to re-target OOH audiences and deliver dynamic creative.

That’s not to say OOH’s transition to programmatic will be simple. Buyers will expect a CPM approach, and that means getting a better understanding of the number of ‘impressions’ generated by a DOOH ad spot or loop in what remains, fundamentally, a one-to-many medium.

Again, transparency will be essential here. Out-of-home currently suffers none of digital’s difficulties when it comes to ad fraud, and the industry must agree how it can work to translate footfall at a digital poster into a robust impression-based metric.

Without these necessary developments in data and infrastructure, and without challenging the legacy models that underpin media planning and buying in OOH, the sector is stuck. Programmatic represents a huge opportunity but so far it has promised much and delivered relatively little. Now is the time for change.

Dan Larden is strategic partnerships director, global, Infectious Media

Leave a comment

Thank you for your comment - a copy has now been sent to the Mediatel Newsline team who will review it shortly. Please note that the editor may edit your comment before publication.

NigelClarkson, Chief Revenue officer, Exterion Media on 6 Jun 2018
“Head of programmatic business in shock ‘OOH should do more programmatic’ claim....

So here’s the thing, and it’s the usual challenge, that people confuse automation, programmatic and real time buying.

The whole OOH business is certainly looking towards automating more of its processes, because why wouldn’t you? But programmatic is a much more convoluted and complicated process that in theory seems ideal, in practice creates more issues than solutions.

Look at the work done by countless publishers (namely the Guardian) about how much money from the client hits the publisher eventually (in some instances, just 30p in the pound). And where that 70% disappears to is pretty much anyone’s guess. If Dan thinks that is progressive and transparent and something we should all be pushing then I will start right away....”
jamescopley, Managing Director, Talon Outdoor on 6 Jun 2018
“Agree Tim. To claim that the programmatic world is bastion of transparency that OOH can aspire to is one sip of the Kool Aid too far for me. As discussed in Talon's Smarter As Standard Manifesto - there is much to learn from the programmatic world and the responsible players in the market are busy investing in technology specifically designed for the OOH world that will supercharge the delivery of effective and efficient OOH campaigns for clients. We are focused on making OOH easier to buy for online advertisers, but not losing sight of how OOH works and the power of one-to-many advertising.”
TimBleakley, CEO, Ocean on 6 Jun 2018
“The theory is strong but much like the England football team it looks great on paper but it’s s*** on grass. I’m not sure we want the same type of transparency delivered as the mobile & internet giants - basically a giant complicit con and whilst the margin enhancement benefits are clear for all I’m yet to see an algorithm that can detect the difference between a paper & paste billboard facing the wrong way down a one way street & an iconic gateway asset entering any major city across the globe . That’s not to say that your vision is not the right direction of travel and we should all strive to change faster but we need to be careful what we wish for . The approach you describe was designed for a particular form of comms and our medium , the last broadcast , high impact , unavoidable , brand safe , highly targeted , location based medium needs an automated system of its own , not an adaptation of something that’s starting to show big cracks .
More on the P word @ FEPE I hear .”


08 Jul 2020 

Data from Mediatel Connected
Find out more about the UK's most comprehensive aggregator of media data.

Arrange a demo

Mediatel News bulletins

Receive weekly round-ups of the latest comment, opinion and media news, direct to your inbox.

More Info
Sign up now